9 Notable Examples of HIPAA Violation: Your Essential Guide!

Updated November 16th, 2023
HIPAA violation examples

Share this article

A HIPAA violation occurs when there is a breach of the standards set by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996. HIPAA is a U.S. law designed to provide privacy standards to protect patients’ medical records and other health information provided to health plans, doctors, hospitals, and other healthcare providers.

Modern data problems require modern solutions - Try Atlan, the data catalog of choice for forward-looking data teams! 👉 Book your demo today

Violations can occur in various ways as mentioned below. In this article, we will study the following violations using examples and how to prevent them.

  1. Unauthorized disclosure of protected health information (PHI): Sharing PHI without the patient’s consent or knowledge, except for permitted disclosures (like for treatment, payment, or healthcare operations), constitutes a violation.
  2. Improper safeguarding of PHI: Failure to adequately secure PHI, whether in electronic or physical form, leading to unauthorized access or breaches.
  3. Unauthorized access to PHI: Accessing PHI for reasons not related to job responsibilities, or by individuals who do not have a legitimate need to know.
  4. Failure to provide patients access to their records: Not allowing patients to view or obtain a copy of their health records within the required timeframe.
  5. Lack of training or awareness: Employees who handle PHI must receive regular training on HIPAA rules. A lack of training can lead to accidental violations.
  6. Failure to notify of a reach: Covered entities must notify affected individuals, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), and sometimes the media, in the event of a breach involving unsecured PHI.
  7. Improper disposal of PHI: PHI should be disposed of securely. Improper disposal methods, like throwing documents in the trash without shredding, can lead to violations.
  8. Texting or emailing PHI without proper security: Sending PHI through unsecured channels, like regular email or text messages, without appropriate encryption, is a violation.
  9. Social media misuse: Sharing any PHI on social media platforms, regardless of the intent, is a violation.

Violations of HIPAA can result in substantial fines, legal action, and damage to the reputation of the individuals and organizations involved. It’s important for all entities handling PHI to strictly adhere to HIPAA regulations to avoid these consequences.

Let’s look at each one of them in detail with examples.

Table of contents #

  1. HIPAA violation Examples: 9 Notable examples & preventives
  2. Unauthorized disclosure of PHI
  3. Improper safeguarding of PHI
  4. Unauthorized access to PHI
  5. Failure to provide patients access to their records
  6. Lack of training or awareness
  7. Failure to notify of a reach
  8. Improper disposal of PHI
  9. Texting or emailing PHI without proper security
  10. Social media misuse
  11. Summing up
  12. HIPAA violation examples: Related reads

HIPAA violation Examples: 9 Notable examples & preventives #

1. Unauthorized disclosure of PHI #

Unauthorized disclosure of protected health information (PHI) occurs when someone with access to PHI shares it without the patient’s consent or a legitimate reason. This can happen in various settings, often unintentionally, due to a lack of awareness or negligence.

Example of unauthorized disclosure #

Imagine a scenario where a clinic receptionist, Emma, accidentally sends a patient’s medical records to the wrong email address. This act constitutes an unauthorized disclosure of PHI because the information was shared without the patient’s consent and sent to an unintended recipient.

How to avoid unauthorized disclosure #

To prevent such incidents, healthcare providers and organizations can implement several measures:

Employee training:

  • Regularly train staff on HIPAA compliance and the importance of safeguarding PHI.
  • Include real-world scenarios in training to help employees understand the consequences of unauthorized disclosures.

Strict access controls:

  • Limit access to PHI only to those who need it for their job functions.
  • Use secure systems to track who accesses PHI and for what purpose.

Secure communication channels:

  • Implement and enforce policies for securely communicating PHI, such as using encrypted emails.
  • Discourage the sharing of PHI through unsecured platforms like text messages or social media.

Regular audits and monitoring:

  • Conduct periodic audits to ensure compliance with policies.
  • Monitor the handling of PHI to quickly identify and rectify any potential unauthorized disclosures.

Patient consent forms:

  • Ensure that patients sign consent forms that clearly state how their information can be used and shared.
  • Regularly update consent forms and policies to reflect any changes in how PHI is managed.

Reporting mechanisms:

  • Establish clear procedures for reporting any breaches or suspected unauthorized disclosures.
  • Encourage a culture of accountability and openness to ensure staff report incidents without fear of retaliation.
  • By taking these steps, healthcare organizations can significantly reduce the risk of unauthorized disclosure of PHI, ensuring compliance with HIPAA regulations and maintaining the trust and privacy of their patients.

2. Improper safeguarding of PHI #

Improper safeguarding of protected health information (PHI) refers to the failure to adequately protect patient data, either in electronic or physical form. This can lead to unauthorized access, theft, or breaches, posing a significant risk to patient privacy and security.

Example of improper safeguarding #

A common example is a medical office leaving patient files in open, unsecured areas where unauthorized persons can access them. Another instance is the use of unencrypted laptops or mobile devices to store PHI, which, if lost or stolen, could lead to a data breach.

How to avoid improper safeguarding #

Here are key measures to enhance the protection of PHI:

Physical security measures:

  • Keep patient records in locked cabinets or secure areas accessible only to authorized personnel.
  • Ensure that the physical premises of the healthcare facility are secure, especially areas where PHI is stored.

Digital security protocols:

  • Use encryption for storing and transmitting PHI electronically.
  • Implement strong passwords and regular password updates for systems storing PHI.

Employee training and awareness:

  • Educate staff about the importance of PHI security.
  • Train them on best practices for handling and storing PHI securely.

Access control:

  • Implement role-based access to PHI, ensuring only necessary personnel can access specific information.
  • Regularly review and update access permissions.

Regular risk assessments:

  • Conduct periodic assessments to identify and address vulnerabilities in PHI protection.
  • Update security measures based on the findings of these assessments.

Data backup and recovery plans:

  • Regularly back up PHI to secure locations.
  • Have a disaster recovery plan in place to restore PHI in case of data loss.

Secure disposal of PHI:

  • Shred physical documents containing PHI before disposal.
  • Use secure methods to delete electronic PHI from devices that are being retired or replaced.

By implementing these strategies, healthcare providers can significantly improve the safeguarding of PHI, ensuring compliance with HIPAA regulations and safeguarding patient trust and privacy.

3. Unauthorized access to PHI #

Unauthorized access to protected health information (PHI) occurs when individuals who do not have a legitimate need to view or use this information access it anyway. This can happen within healthcare settings due to inadequate security measures or oversight.

Example of unauthorized access #

A situation that illustrates this is when a hospital staff member, who does not need to access PHI for their job duties, views a patient’s medical records out of curiosity. This is a clear violation as the staff member does not have a legitimate reason to access that information.

How to avoid unauthorized access #

To prevent unauthorized access to PHI, healthcare organizations can adopt several strategies:

Strict access controls:

  • Limit PHI access strictly to personnel who need it for their job functions.
  • Use access control systems like passwords and user IDs to track who accesses PHI.

Regular training and awareness programs:

  • Educate all employees about the importance of maintaining the confidentiality of PHI.
  • Highlight the consequences of unauthorized access in training sessions.

Monitoring and auditing:

  • Implement systems to monitor access to PHI and regularly audit these records.
  • Quickly investigate any unusual or unauthorized access patterns.

Physical security measures:

  • Ensure that areas where PHI is stored are secure and accessible only to authorized personnel.
  • Use security cameras and alarms to deter and detect unauthorized access in physical locations.

Policies and procedures:

  • Develop clear policies defining authorized access and the process for obtaining it.
  • Establish protocols for reporting and responding to incidents of unauthorized access.

Role-based access:

  • Assign access levels based on the employee’s role within the organization.
  • Regularly update access permissions as roles or job functions change.

Use of encryption and secure networks:

  • Encrypt PHI, especially when stored or transmitted electronically.
  • Use secure networks for accessing PHI to prevent external breaches.

By implementing these measures, healthcare organizations can significantly reduce the risk of unauthorized access to PHI, thereby ensuring patient privacy and compliance with HIPAA regulations.

4. Failure to provide patients access to their records #

Failure to provide patients access to their records happens when healthcare providers do not allow patients to view or obtain copies of their health information within a reasonable time frame. Under HIPAA, patients have the right to access their health records, and denying or delaying this access is a violation.

Example of failure to provide access #

An example of this could be a scenario where a patient requests a copy of their medical records, but the healthcare provider delays or refuses to provide the information without a valid reason. This not only violates HIPAA regulations but also impedes the patient’s right to their own health information.

How to ensure patients have access to their records #

To avoid such issues, healthcare providers can adopt the following practices:

Clear policies and procedures:

  • Establish and communicate clear procedures for patients to request their health records.
  • Ensure that all staff members are aware of these procedures.

Timely response to requests:

  • Respond to patient requests for access to records in a timely manner, typically within 30 days as required by HIPAA.
  • Inform patients promptly if there is a legitimate reason for any delay.

Secure and convenient access methods:

  • Provide multiple secure methods for patients to request and receive their records, such as online portals, mail, or in-person pickups.
  • Offer electronic copies of records if requested.

Regular staff training:

  • Train staff on the importance of patient access to health information and the legal requirements for providing access.
  • Include scenarios and role-plays in training to ensure staff understand how to handle requests properly.

Audit and monitoring systems:

  • Implement systems to monitor compliance with policies related to patient access requests.
  • Regularly audit the process of handling these requests to identify and rectify any shortcomings.

Minimal fees:

  • Only charge a reasonable fee for providing copies of health records, as allowed by law.
  • Clearly communicate any potential costs to patients upfront.

Patient education:

  • Inform patients about their rights to access their health records.
  • Provide clear instructions on how to make a request for their records.

By following these guidelines, healthcare providers can ensure they are compliant with HIPAA regulations and respect the rights of patients to access their own health information.

5. Lack of training or awareness #

Lack of training or awareness in handling protected health information (PHI) refers to situations where healthcare staff are not adequately educated on HIPAA regulations and the proper management of PHI. This can lead to unintentional violations and breaches of patient privacy.

Example of lack of training or awareness #

An example might be a new employee at a clinic who hasn’t been trained on HIPAA compliance. They might inadvertently discuss a patient’s condition with unauthorized individuals, not understanding the privacy requirements for such information.

How to address lack of training or awareness #

To mitigate these risks, healthcare organizations should focus on the following strategies:

Comprehensive training programs:

  • Provide mandatory HIPAA training for all new hires.
  • Ensure ongoing training for all staff to keep them updated on HIPAA regulations and best practices.

Regular updates and refreshers:

  • Offer periodic refresher courses to keep staff informed about any changes in HIPAA laws or organizational policies.
  • Use newsletters, emails, or brief meetings to share updates and reminders.

Practical training sessions:

  • Include real-life scenarios and role-playing exercises in training to help staff understand the application of HIPAA rules in daily activities.
  • Encourage interactive sessions where employees can ask questions and discuss past experiences.

Creating a culture of compliance:

  • Foster an organizational culture that prioritizes patient privacy and the security of PHI.
  • Encourage staff to report any potential privacy concerns or breaches without fear of retaliation.

Accessible resources and support:

  • Provide easily accessible resources, such as manuals or online portals, where employees can find information about HIPAA compliance.
  • Assign a designated privacy officer or a go-to team for staff to approach with questions or concerns regarding PHI handling.

Monitoring and evaluation:

  • Regularly assess the effectiveness of the training programs.
  • Monitor staff practices to identify areas where additional training or awareness is needed.

Incorporating feedback:

  • Seek feedback from employees about the training programs and use this input to make necessary improvements.
  • Address specific challenges or misunderstandings that staff might have about HIPAA regulations.

By addressing the lack of training or awareness, healthcare providers can significantly reduce the risk of HIPAA violations, ensuring a safer and more compliant handling of patient information.

6. Failure to notify of a breach #

Failure to notify of a breach refers to not informing the appropriate parties when there is a confirmed breach of protected health information (PHI).

Under HIPAA, healthcare entities are required to notify affected individuals, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), and in some cases, the media, if there is a breach involving unsecured PHI.

Example of failure to notify of a breach #

Imagine a situation where a healthcare provider’s database is hacked, exposing patient records. If the provider does not inform the affected patients and the HHS about this breach within the required timeframe, it constitutes a failure to notify.

How to ensure proper breach notification #

To comply with HIPAA regulations regarding breach notifications, healthcare organizations should:

Develop a breach response plan:

  • Have a clear, written plan outlining the steps to take when a breach occurs.
  • Ensure the plan includes procedures for identifying the breach, assessing its impact, and notifying the appropriate parties.

Train staff on breach response:

  • Conduct regular training for all employees on how to recognize and report a breach.
  • Make sure staff understand their roles and responsibilities in the breach notification process.

Timely notification:

  • Notify affected individuals, the HHS, and sometimes the media without unnecessary delay and no later than 60 days after discovering the breach.
  • Provide all required information in the notification, including a description of the breach, the types of information involved, and steps individuals should take to protect themselves.

Documentation and record-keeping:

  • Keep records of the breach and the notification process.
  • Document the reasons for any delays in notification, if applicable.

Regular review and updates of policies:

  • Regularly review and update breach notification policies and procedures to ensure they remain effective and compliant with current laws.

Internal reporting systems:

  • Implement an effective internal reporting system for employees to report breaches.
  • Encourage a culture of prompt reporting and transparency.

Assessment and revision post-breach:

  • After a breach occurs and notifications are sent, assess the effectiveness of the response.
  • Revise policies and procedures based on lessons learned to improve future responses.

By following these steps, healthcare organizations can ensure they are prepared to properly notify all necessary parties in the event of a PHI breach, thereby maintaining compliance with HIPAA regulations and preserving patient trust.

7. Improper disposal of PHI #

Improper disposal of protected health information (PHI) occurs when healthcare entities fail to dispose of PHI securely, potentially leading to unauthorized access or breaches. HIPAA requires that PHI, whether in paper or electronic form, be disposed of in a way that protects the information from unauthorized access.

Example of improper disposal #

A typical example is a medical clinic disposing of old patient records by simply throwing them in the trash or recycling bin without shredding. This makes the information accessible to anyone who comes across it, resulting in a violation of HIPAA regulations.

How to ensure proper disposal of PHI #

To prevent the risks associated with improper disposal, healthcare organizations can implement the following practices:

Develop and enforce disposal policies:

  • Establish clear, written policies for the disposal of PHI.
  • Ensure that these policies comply with HIPAA regulations and cover all forms of PHI.

Training and awareness for staff:

  • Train all employees on proper disposal procedures.
  • Regularly remind staff of the importance of secure disposal practices.

Secure disposal methods:

  • Shred or otherwise destroy paper records so that PHI is unreadable and cannot be reconstructed.
  • For electronic PHI, use methods like wiping, degaussing, or physically destroying the media to ensure information cannot be retrieved.

Vendor agreements for disposal:

  • If using external vendors for disposal, ensure they are aware of and comply with HIPAA requirements.
  • Have a signed business associate agreement (BAA) with the vendor that covers the handling and disposal of PHI.

Regular audits and monitoring:

  • Conduct periodic audits to ensure that disposal policies are being followed.
  • Monitor the disposal process, especially when external vendors are involved.

Disposal documentation:

  • Keep records of when and how PHI was disposed of.
  • Document the process to provide evidence of compliance in case of an audit.

Review and update disposal practices:

  • Regularly review and update disposal practices to keep up with changes in technology and regulations.
  • Address any new forms of PHI or changes in how PHI is stored and used within the organization.

By adhering to these guidelines, healthcare organizations can effectively mitigate the risks associated with the improper disposal of PHI, ensuring compliance with HIPAA and safeguarding patient privacy.

8. Texting or emailing PHI without proper security #

Texting or emailing protected health information (PHI) without proper security is a common HIPAA violation. This occurs when PHI is sent over communication channels that are not secure, potentially exposing the information to unauthorized individuals.

Example of insecure communication #

An example is a doctor sending a patient’s medical details to a colleague via a regular, unencrypted email for a consultation. Since standard email is not secure, this action risks exposing the patient’s PHI to unauthorized parties.

How to ensure secure communication of PHI #

To prevent breaches through insecure communication, healthcare organizations should adopt these measures:

Implement secure messaging systems:

  • Use secure, encrypted messaging platforms specifically designed for transmitting PHI.
  • Ensure that any system used for texting or emailing PHI complies with HIPAA security standards.

Training and policies on secure communication:

  • Develop clear policies regarding the transmission of PHI.
  • Train all staff on these policies and the importance of using secure channels for communication.

Regular monitoring and audits:

  • Monitor communications to ensure compliance with secure messaging policies.
  • Conduct regular audits to identify and address any lapses in secure communication practices.

Encrypted email systems:

  • If email must be used for transmitting PHI, ensure it is encrypted and meets HIPAA standards.
  • Teach staff how to use encrypted email systems properly.

Patient consent and secure patient portals:

  • Obtain patient consent before sharing their PHI.
  • Use secure patient portals for communication, which are more secure than regular email or text messages.

Access controls and authentication:

  • Implement strong authentication procedures to access communication systems.
  • Limit access to PHI to authorized personnel only.

Update and review communication technologies:

  • Regularly update communication technologies to ensure they provide adequate security.
  • Review and adjust policies as new communication technologies and threats emerge.

By ensuring that all texting and emailing of PHI is conducted over secure, encrypted channels, healthcare organizations can significantly reduce the risk of unauthorized access to patient information, thereby maintaining compliance with HIPAA regulations and ensuring patient privacy.

9. Social media misuse #

Social media misuse involving protected health information (PHI) happens when healthcare providers or employees share PHI on social media platforms without patient consent. This is a direct violation of HIPAA privacy rules, as it compromises patient confidentiality.

Example of social media misuse #

An example could be a healthcare worker posting a photo on social media from a hospital ward that inadvertently includes patient information or a patient in the background. Even if the post is well-intentioned, it violates patient privacy.

How to avoid social media misuse #

To safeguard against such breaches, healthcare organizations can implement the following strategies:

Clear social media policies:

  • Develop and enforce strict policies regarding the use of social media in relation to PHI.
  • Clarify what constitutes inappropriate sharing of PHI on these platforms.

Regular training and education:

  • Provide regular training to all staff on the proper use of social media in a healthcare context.
  • Highlight the potential risks and consequences of mishandling PHI on social media.

Monitoring and enforcement:

  • Monitor social media usage as it relates to the workplace.
  • Enforce policies strictly and consistently to deter potential violations.

Secure patient consent:

  • Obtain explicit patient consent before posting any information or images that could potentially identify them, even in cases where PHI is not obvious.
  • Ensure staff understand the legal and ethical requirements for obtaining consent.

Prompt response to violations:

  • Establish procedures for quickly addressing any social media misuse.
  • Include steps for removing inappropriate content and addressing the breach with the involved employee.

Promoting privacy-aware culture:

  • Foster a workplace culture that prioritizes patient privacy and understands the implications of social media use.
  • Encourage staff to report any potential or actual breaches they observe.

Review and update policies regularly:

  • Keep social media policies up-to-date with evolving technologies and platforms.
  • Adapt policies to address new types of social media and changing usage patterns.

By proactively managing social media use and educating staff on the risks and regulations associated with sharing PHI, healthcare organizations can prevent privacy violations and maintain compliance with HIPAA guidelines.

Summing up #

The landscape of healthcare data management demands unwavering commitment to privacy and security. The array of challenges presented by potential HIPAA violations emphasizes the critical need for proactive, multifaceted solutions.

By cultivating a culture of awareness, continuous training, and stringent compliance, healthcare organizations can navigate the complexities of safeguarding patient information. In doing so, they not only ensure regulatory adherence but also uphold the trust and confidentiality integral to the healthcare profession.

As technology evolves and new challenges emerge, the commitment to protecting Protected Health Information remains a steadfast cornerstone of responsible healthcare practices.

Share this article

[Website env: production]